27 February 2009

I'm alright, Fred.

A lot has been said this week is about Sir Fred Goodwin, former Head of RBS, for refusing to relinquish his full pension. And of course it would be easy and childish to add to that furore. But no less fun for all that.

Most of the anger seems directed at the amount of money Sir Fred will get every year for his pension. Now I accept that £675,000 is a lot of money. Some would say £1 is a lot of money for Sir Fred to walk away with, given the circumstances. But rather than focus on the amount, I prefer to look at the reasons why Sir Fred believes he has nothing to apologise for in taking that much every year. Yesterday, he published a letter written to the government explaining why he would be declining their kind offer to give up some of his entitlement, which boils down to three arguments - let's look at them in a bit more detail:

1) According to Sir Fred:

My contract of employment provided for a 12 month notice period, which I voluntarily waived in October of last year. This amounted to a loss of 1 years' [sic] salary, and I discussed this with you at the time, when you indicated that it was both an appropriate and sufficient recognition of the circumstances.

To my mind, notice periods are what you work when you resign. In other words, to leave a company on good terms. If I had exposed the company I work for to a risk that would ultimately prove ruinous, I think I might reasonably expect to be fired. No notice period. In allowing Sir Fred the dignity of his exit, quibbling about notice payment might seem undignified.

2) Sir Fred's second argument is that the pension represents the acme of all the work he has done over his banking career. Poor Sir Fred, spending all those years toiling away at the coalface of high finance, with only an exorbitant salary for reward.

I call this the Leni Riefenstahl argument. Leni always bemoaned wistfully, during her long life after World War 2, that no-one would see her post-war films, preferring instead to focus on the time she spent making films for Hitler. Such a shame, people can be such gossips.

This is a similar line peddled recently by The Economist - that we shouldn't be quick to judge the Banking industry, while forgetting about how rich it made us the the previous 20 years, though I note that even The Economist seems to have dropped that argument of late. I prefer to draw the analogy of the use of asbestos as roofing materials in many buildings, which has been exposed as a public health hazard. Rather than focus on the cancer it has caused, maybe we should instead be grateful for the shelter the roof gave us for 20 years?

3) The best argument of all is how Sir Fred nobly has forgone all claims to share options he would have been entitled to:

I agreed to waive my entitlement to the share related awards and proceeded to subscribe for my full allocation of shares in the ensuing share issue.

I wonder how much, exactly, such shares would be worth now? In fact - go on, Sir Fred, knock yourself out. Take as many RBS shares as you can fit into those grasping mits. I tell you what, we'll do a deal - all the RBS shares for your pension entitlement. What do you say?

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.thomassaboss.co.uk]thomas sabo classic[/url] Of course, these people are heretics (and I can say this because I used to be one of them until I realized the error of my ways).. [url=http://www.zoeroad.com]vintage prom dresses uk[/url]
[url=http://www.christianlouboutinosale.co.uk]christian louboutin outlet online[/url] zyoutqrz These devices are great for showing you where you're at and how to get to your destination. emhvoiai [url=http://www.mulberrylondonshop.co.uk]mulberry shoulder bags sale[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.dressaleuk.co.uk]prom dresses cheap online[/url] It seemed like the water buffalo did not begrudge Rat Kiley for torturing it, but merely thought it was unfortunate that Kiley had chosen him to vent his anger on. [url=http://www.zoeroad.com]princess prom dresses[/url]
[url=http://www.xmpllc.com]homing dress 2013[/url] oyruvbtb YouTube - Ass licking Dog Taylor Rain hardcore anal ****. ufgdsezf [url=http://www.mulberrylondonshop.co.uk]mulberry purse sale[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.dressaleuk.co.uk]prom dresses on sale online[/url] It can be broken down into four stages: childhood freedoms, student life's discipline, married life's family closeness and old age's reflections. [url=http://www.zoeroad.com]girls prom dresses[/url]
[url=http://www.xmpllc.com]dress outlet shop[/url] ghyzpspt It is a great time that thousands look forward to every year. okkaxjyc [url=http://www.mulberrylondonshop.co.uk]mulberry bags sale uk[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.bestdresseller.co.uk]cheap formal gowns[/url] Wilma, for example, wandered in to the Gulf of Mexico and in less than two hours, broke all records going from a Catagory 1 to a high Catagory 5 hurricane. http://www.mitwhite.com
[url=http://www.xmpllc.com]short homecoming dresses[/url] ywotmxup Sometimes God will walk the evil spirits around, operate their vehicles, use their password and access their computer-allowing them to "watch", move their arms, legs and hands in a strange way, but allowing them the opportunity to think and speak. xeygzdlp [url=http://www.mulberrylondonshop.co.uk]mulberry mitzy bags[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.dressaleuk.co.uk]prom dresses sale[/url] "It's a good way to get people to talk about things they ordinarily wouldn't," says New Jersey Stockbroker Michael Deutsch, 39. [url=http://www.mitwhite.com]cheap bridesmaid dresses[/url]
[url=http://www.xmpllc.com]short homecoming dresses[/url] uxgnmthn So our house is too pitiful for me to invite any friends home (don't believe any other rumour you might hear). tqvrzrkq [url=http://www.mulberrylondonshop.co.uk]mulberry handbags uk[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.bestdresseller.co.uk]short party dresses[/url] The ride will take us through the some of the most scenic spots along the Pacific Coast Highway. [url=http://www.zoeroad.com]http://www.zoeroad.com[/url]
[url=http://www.xmpllc.com]wedding dresses vera wang[/url] rokxcqvz When you transfer a large amount the exchange rate you will be offered will be far closer to the commercial rate. yxojwvus [url=http://www.mulberrylondonshop.co.uk]mulberry mitzy bags[/url]

Anonymous said...

http://www.dressaleuk.co.uk Hidden along a dirt road on Maui's North Shore, the tropical estate overlooks ethereal views of plunging lava cliffs. [url=http://www.mitwhite.com]vintage bridesmaid dresses[/url]
[url=http://www.christianlouboutinosale.co.uk]louboutin outlet[/url] jpqmdpyl Look for companies closing down, or to closeout and liquidation companies for some great buys.. hveaxscg [url=http://www.mulberrylondonshop.co.uk]mulberry sale shop[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.bestdresseller.co.uk]party dresses for juniors[/url] They provide better support and gone are the days of itchy pillows. [url=http://www.zoeroad.com]http://www.zoeroad.com[/url]
[url=http://www.xmpllc.com]homecoming dress stores[/url] zqudkbbb I don't know how many activations of this button it takes to delete a post, but I would think, 5 independent activations should be more than sufficient. vcpyvbhb [url=http://www.mulberrylondonshop.co.uk]mulberry handbags outle[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.bestdresseller.co.uk]cheap party dresses[/url] So the poor animals -loads of them stand around bleeding all over since they have no skin. [url=http://www.zoeroad.com]http://www.zoeroad.com[/url]
[url=http://www.xmpllc.com]plus size homecoming dresses[/url] whtbynhh However I'm sure that many workflows have instances where they want the ability to go back and tidy up some minor issue, which an early deletion would make awkward. ogzprtei [url=http://www.mulberrylondonshop.co.uk]mulberry sale uk[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.bestdresseller.co.uk]party dresses for girls[/url] But we have to be quiet this time, because apparently theres nothing more annoying then screaming rich girls. [url=http://www.zoeroad.com]unique prom dresses[/url]
[url=http://www.christianlouboutinosale.co.uk]louboutin uk[/url] frndppvl Many study materials I found do not follow the CPIM exam content manual which was confusing to know what do I exactly need to learn to pass. vbtnbvzv [url=http://www.mulberrylondonshop.co.uk]mulberry handbags outle[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.bestdresseller.co.uk]plus size party dresses[/url] This monument will ensure that visitors to our State Capitol will have the opportunity to learn about and celebrate great Virginia women. [url=http://www.zoeroad.com]prom dresses online[/url]
[url=http://www.xmpllc.com]wedding dresses vera wang[/url] wlwwwsfb Richard Warren . bkqequkh [url=http://www.mulberrylondonshop.co.uk]mulberry uk[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.dressaleuk.co.uk]prom dresses sale[/url] No, both tried to either expand or plot to expand their military-based conquests! Sounds familiar?. [url=http://www.zoeroad.com]long prom dresses uk[/url]
http://www.christianlouboutinosale.co.uk yjyekiww Please call before dropping in without an appointment. rkdnucru [url=http://www.mulberrylondonshop.co.uk]mulberry outlet[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.bestdresseller.co.uk]1discount formal dresses[/url] "Snow!" If the involves 8 about 40 components, large snowflakes mingled even though it is pouring down rain through the column azure heavens wh3021best. [url=http://www.zoeroad.com]princess prom dresses[/url]
[url=http://www.xmpllc.com]homing dress 2013[/url] fizzxhnn "Ustvarjalcev in skupin ne manjka. xnamfcxa [url=http://www.amazingprom.com]http://www.amazingprom.com[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.bestdresseller.co.uk]cheap formal gowns[/url] You get three or four flavors you want and the ten you don't want but it comes with the pack. [url=http://www.zoeroad.com]http://www.zoeroad.com[/url]
[url=http://www.xmpllc.com]vintage wedding dress[/url] gfeayson In addition you can access the ?Verb Commands? menu by typing in the command go verb. agjsqvzh [url=http://www.amazingprom.com]prom dresses under 100[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.mujeresvestidos.com/]vestidos de novia 2013[/url] The heavy rains we are seeing today could possibly be from the moisture in the atmosphere gathering around these fluffy pieces of volcanic ash and coming crashing down in extremely large rain drops. [url=http://www.zoeroad.com]prom dresses online[/url]
[url=http://www.xmpllc.com]wedding dress online sale[/url] hnxzxuqe G. rezesivf [url=http://www.amazingprom.com]prom dress stores[/url]